Chapter 1: The Myth of the Meat-Heavy Diet

Cultural representations often portray our ancestors as robust hunters, primarily consuming meat. This has led many to adopt diets such as Paleo and keto, which emphasize high protein and low carbohydrates. However, recent studies indicate that Neanderthals included substantial amounts of starchy carbs in their diets as they migrated from eastern Africa into Europe.

Traces of ancient bacteria found on Neanderthal teeth suggest that as early as 600,000 years ago, our ancestors relied on carbohydrate-rich plant foods to sustain their growing brain sizes. This research, conducted by a team from Harvard University and the Max Planck Institute, reveals a more complex dietary strategy than the simplistic meat-centric view.

“This idea that early humans were primarily hunters is likely misguided,” noted Christina Warinner, a Harvard anthropologist and co-author of the study. “The notion of the Paleo diet doesn’t accurately reflect the Paleolithic era; it’s a misinterpretation.”

This paragraph will result in an indented block of text, typically used for quoting other text.

Section 1.1: The Evidence from Ancestors' Teeth

The genus Homo, which includes modern humans, emerged during the Paleolithic period, roughly 2.5 million years ago, replacing earlier human ancestors known as Australopiths. Initially, it was believed that the consumption of meat was the primary factor behind the rapid expansion of brain size in early humans. Yet, Warinner remains skeptical, emphasizing that glucose from carbohydrates is crucial for brain development.

Many studies assessing Neanderthal diets relied on carbon-nitrogen ratios in their remains, which can be misleading due to other influencing factors such as periods of fasting. Warinner’s team analyzed DNA from bacteria fossilized on ancient teeth, comparing samples from 124 living and extinct primates. The findings revealed that Neanderthals shared similar mouth bacteria with modern humans, indicating a common dietary component: starch.

Chapter 2: Challenging Modern Diets

The findings challenge the principles of the Paleo diet, which largely excludes grains and starchy foods in favor of meat, fish, and vegetables. The keto diet goes even further, drastically limiting carb intake in favor of fats and proteins, primarily derived from meat sources.

Low-carb diets prompt the body to create glucose via gluconeogenesis, utilizing fat and protein. However, Warinner argues that early humans did not rely on these metabolic processes. “Producing your own glucose requires a significant amount of dietary fat,” she explained.

Video Description: Anthropologist Christina Warinner discusses the misconceptions surrounding the Paleo diet and the nutritional habits of our ancestors.

The majority of terrestrial animals hunted by Neanderthals lacked substantial fat reserves. “Populations that have thrived on low-carb diets often have relied on marine mammals, which store significant fat,” Warinner stated.

Ultimately, drawing comparisons between contemporary diets and those of our ancestors is flawed, as modern lifestyles differ vastly from the foraging existence of early humans.

Video Description: SciShow News explores the evidence showing that humans have historically embraced carbohydrates long before the advent of modern diets.

The starchy foods consumed by our ancestors were not the same as today's processed carbs; they were nutrient-dense, fibrous, and rich in vitamins. “It's unfair to equate wild root vegetables with modern pizza and pasta; their nutritional profiles are profoundly different,” Warinner pointed out.

There’s limited evidence to suggest that the Paleo or keto diets provide significant benefits over other whole-food diets rich in nutrients. “We don’t need to regress 10,000 years to achieve a healthy lifestyle,” Warinner concluded.

For more great stories, visit Insider’s homepage.