Understanding Self-Managing Teams: A Modern Approach to Leadership
Written on
Chapter 1: Defining Self-Managing Teams
A few weeks ago, I penned an article discussing the diminishing effectiveness of scaling frameworks within agile organizations. This sparked numerous insightful inquiries, particularly one that stood out:
"Many Agile coaches frequently mention 'self-managing' teams. What exactly does that mean? Do they truly grasp its significance?" — Cliff Berg
This led to an engaging dialogue, uncovering essential questions: Are there designated leaders in Scrum? Do leaders naturally emerge within teams, and how should we address this inner circle? Has Scrum overlooked traditional leadership attributes?
These inquiries reveal a significant tension between conventional, hierarchical organizational structures and more interconnected frameworks where responsibilities are distributed among team members. Each structure has its advantages and disadvantages, but they yield markedly different results.
Building Blocks of Self-Managing Teams
Let's delve into the core aspects of effective self-managing teams. A self-managed team comprises individuals who take on the responsibility and accountability for most, if not all, facets of product creation or service delivery.
In traditional organizations, tasks are allocated based on employees' expertise or departmental roles. Conversely, self-managed teams not only handle technical responsibilities but also engage in planning, scheduling workflows, and managing absences. Leadership and technical duties are typically shared among team members.
While many organizations still assign goals to their teams, leaving them to determine how to achieve them, progressive companies like Zappos, Google, and Meta allow teams to set their own objectives. This elevates their accountability as they can directly influence strategic outcomes. Such autonomy fosters trust and results in highly motivated teams.
The Role of Leadership in Self-Managing Teams
It's crucial to recognize that leadership remains essential in self-managing teams. Although the manager's role evolves, individuals still require direction, support, and an external perspective.
This environment allows managers to truly listen to team needs, focusing on impactful processes while team members address routine challenges. For managers, this is an opportunity to embody servant leadership by removing obstacles that hinder team autonomy.
Moreover, team members are empowered to develop their leadership capabilities in ways that were previously unavailable. Being micromanaged can stifle creativity and innovation; however, when individuals can present their ideas and contribute to significant outcomes, motivation soars.
The Factory Mentality vs. Empowered Teams
Traditionally managed software development teams often treat employees like factory workers, dictating tasks, methods, timelines, and, occasionally, the rationale behind their work.
In contrast, individuals in product management and software development possess creativity and problem-solving skills that should be leveraged. Our work is inherently empirical; we learn what to do through experience. Who better to decide on tasks than those actively engaged in the work?
Harnessing the collective intelligence of the team rather than filtering all ideas through a single manager is the more effective approach. This method thrives when working with capable individuals in a mature team, resulting in completed projects and continuous growth—benefiting the organization significantly, as evidenced by companies like Google.
For those who adhere to traditional management styles, stay tuned for my upcoming article on the challenges faced by self-managing teams.
Thank you for reading my blog! I welcome your thoughts in the comments or via direct message. Likes and shares are greatly appreciated! My writing focuses on agility, software development, organizational change, team dynamics, career insights, and my decade-long experience in product management. Follow me if you're interested in these topics.
Chapter 2: Video Insights on Self-Managing Teams
To enrich your understanding, here are two insightful videos on self-managing teams.
The first video, "Self–managed Teams: An insider's story | Helen Sanderson | TEDxUniversityofHertfordshire," explores the dynamics and experiences of self-managing teams in a professional setting.
The second video, "The TRUTH About SELF-MANAGED Teams," dives into the realities and challenges of implementing self-managed teams in various organizations.