The New AI Disruption

We are now on the brink of another major disruption in the music world, this time driven by generative AI. Just as file-sharing apps transformed music distribution, AI is set to revolutionize music creation. However, record companies are taking proactive measures to avoid being blindsided.

At present, much of the music generated by AI lacks coherence and emotional depth. While AI-generated music isn't an immediate threat, an incident in April 2023 changed the landscape: a song titled "Heart on My Sleeve," which replicated the vocals of Drake and The Weeknd, went viral, racking up 15 million streams before being removed. While not entirely AI-created, the use of AI to synthesize vocals sent shockwaves through the industry, signaling a new "Napster moment."

The AI Drake track is a harbinger of challenges to come, potentially impacting revenue streams for creators and rights holders. The industry doesn't just need an umbrella—it requires a robust flood barrier.

• Billboard

Universal Music Group (UMG) swiftly acted to eliminate the AI-generated Drake track from streaming services, asserting that such creations violated copyright laws and existing agreements. Following this, UMG urged streaming platforms to take a stand against AI-generated music. Spotify has been actively removing thousands of songs generated by a platform called Boomy, which has produced over 17 million AI tracks in just two years.

Similar to the original Napster era, concerns about intellectual property rights are resurfacing, and record companies are racing to adapt. This time, however, Google is stepping in with a technological solution.

YouTube's AI Music Initiative

Taking cues from Steve Jobs, YouTube has initiated a partnership with record labels to position itself as the central hub for monetizing AI-generated music. In a recent blog post, YouTube announced its collaboration with music partners, including UMG, to create an AI framework aimed at achieving mutual goals.

“I’m incredibly excited about the opportunity of AI to supercharge creativity around the world, but recognize that YouTube and the promise of AI will only be successful if our partners are successful.”

— Neal Mohan, CEO of YouTube

This initiative, dubbed the AI Music Incubator, involves artists like Anitta, Björn Ulvaeus, Juanes, Max Richter, Rosanne Cash, Ryan Tedder, Yo Gotti, and the Estate of Frank Sinatra. The goal is to explore and provide feedback on AI-driven musical tools that YouTube is developing. Once these tools are available, greater participation from artists is anticipated.

YouTube's AI music principles include:

• Principle #1: Embrace AI responsibly alongside music partners to foster creativity and innovation.
• Principle #2: Ensure that the new age of creative expression includes protections and opportunities for participating music partners.
• Principle #3: Expand trust and safety protocols to meet AI challenges, continuing investment in technology that safeguards the community.

The AI Music Framework

According to the Financial Times, Google is also negotiating with Warner Music. Robert Kyncl, CEO of Warner Music, noted, “With the right framework in place, AI could enable fans to pay their heroes the ultimate compliment through a new level of user-driven content . . . including new cover versions and mash-ups.”

While the specifics of YouTube's new software and framework remain unclear, the AI Music Incubator is the first step toward transforming music creation. The average person, regardless of musical training, will soon be able to compose songs using simple prompts and AI tools, while skilled musicians can produce high-quality music at scale.

YouTube aims to enhance its Content ID technology, a digital fingerprinting system that will help in tracking and managing copyrighted content, thus protecting the rights of creators.

What Lies Ahead?

Currently, YouTube is collaborating with at least two major record companies to explore the potential of AI in music. While the AI Music Incubator encourages experimentation, details about an AI-based monetization system are still forthcoming.

Although AI-generated voiceovers, like Johnny Cash singing ‘Barbie Girl,’ are entertaining, they are merely fleeting trends. Both record and tech companies foresee a future where AI plays a pivotal role in music creation, and they are eager to be part of this new frontier.

There is a possibility that a new category of AI music creators will emerge, potentially giving rise to a genre of AI-native brands.

Final Thoughts

Having grown up in a world where musicians have significantly shaped music culture, it's challenging to envision a future dominated entirely by AI. The emotional connection we share with artists, the live music experience, and the human essence in songwriting suggest that fully AI-generated music may still be some time away. However, the integration of AI technology into music is inevitable, and its evolution will be fascinating to observe.

We are just at the beginning.

If you enjoyed this article, please show some love on Medium—clap, comment, and follow! Engagement helps recognize writers.

This video explores the impact of AI in music, discussing the challenges and opportunities for artists and record labels.

This video dives into the future of music creation and the role of AI, emphasizing a creator-first approach in the music industry.